Director Marc Turteltaub brings Jay Parini’s 2020 memoir to the screen in a biographical adaptation that captures the unlikely bond between a young American doctoral student and the legendary Argentine writer José Luis Borges. Set in 1970s Scotland, the film follows Parini as he unexpectedly becomes caretaker to the aging, blind literary icon during a spontaneous road trip through the Scottish Highlands. What began as a simple arrangement quickly transforms into an unforgettable journey filled with cultural misunderstandings and unexpected moments of connection.
The film benefits significantly from its picturesque Scottish setting, with cinematography that showcases the autumnal landscape with crisp, naturalistic beauty. Luis Gnecco delivers a spirited portrayal of Borges, infusing the character with mischievous wisdom and unbridled curiosity, while Fionn Whitehead captures Parini’s earnest awkwardness as an out-of-place American navigating both his academic pursuits and newfound responsibilities. Alan Cumming rounds out the cast as Parini’s bohemian supervisor, adding warmth to the ensemble.
While the narrative occasionally stretches thin and risks overextending its central premise, the film maintains considerable charm through its gentle, nostalgic tone. Rather than pursuing profundity, it opts for a lighter, more whimsical approach to exploring mentorship and personal growth. The quieter moments between characters prove most resonant, suggesting the film succeeds best when emphasizing intimate human connection over literary grandeur. This accessible, feel-good adaptation appears well-suited for festival circuits and arthouse audiences seeking understated, character-driven storytelling.
Originally reported by Variety →
About the Author
