Celtic has faced criticism over the timing of midfielder Arne Engels’ departure to West Ham United, with the transfer occurring just days before a crucial Champions League playoff double-header against Austrian side LASK. Engels, valued at £25 million, was included in manager Martin O’Neill’s squad for the important European tie before the deal was finalized.
Former Celtic striker Chris Sutton expressed frustration with the club’s decision, arguing that losing such a key player at such a critical juncture undermines their playoff preparations. Sutton highlighted Engels’ influential performances, noting his physical presence and work rate across the midfield were difficult to replace. He acknowledged West Ham’s urgency given their Championship campaign launch, but stressed the responsibility lay with Celtic to prioritize their own sporting interests.
O’Neill has moved to address the midfield gap by bringing in Paderborn’s Miko Baur, though the manager clarified that Baur does not represent a direct replacement for Engels. O’Neill stated the club would continue searching for a box-to-box midfielder with the physicality required to fill Engels’ role. Engels’ final appearance for Celtic came in a 5-1 victory against Kilmarnock, marking his 100th outing for the club.
The timing of the transfer, combined with an earlier injury to defender Alistair Johnston, leaves Celtic in a significantly weakened position heading into their playoff clash. The situation represents a considerable gamble for O’Neill and the club as they prepare for what could prove a pivotal stage of their European campaign.
