“The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives” returned this week for its fifth season, but the show’s central storyline has become increasingly difficult to watch. The series has long revolved around the troubled relationship between influencer Taylor Frankie Paul and her on-and-off boyfriend Dakota Mortensen, beginning with footage of a violent police encounter that resulted in Paul’s guilty plea for aggravated assault.
The situation worsened earlier this year when a planned “Bachelorette” spinoff featuring Paul was canceled after more graphic video of the same incident surfaced publicly. Despite this setback, Paul remains the focal point of the reality show, which aired its abbreviated new season using footage filmed before the scandal broke. The new episodes reveal minimal plot development, including details about Paul’s “Bachelorette” experience that underscore how the relationship already crumbled upon her return home.
What once functioned as entertaining reality television has transformed into something darker and more unsettling. The show’s relentless focus on Paul and Mortensen’s self-destructive cycle—coupled with similar toxic dynamics playing out among other cast members—creates a grim viewing experience rather than the engaging pop culture commentary it once offered. The series now appears trapped by the very storyline that initially fueled its appeal, unable to move beyond the tragedy consuming it.
Originally reported by Variety →
About the Author
